How
Pathologists Were Selected
Consumers' Research Council of
America has compiled a list of Top Pathologists throughout the United
States by utilizing a point value system. This method uses a point value for
criteria that we deemed valuable in determining Top Pathologists.
The criteria that was used and
assessed a point value is as follows:
|
Experience:
|
Each year the Pathologist has been in practice
|
|
Training:
|
Education and Continuing Education
|
|
Professional
Associations:
|
Member of Professional Medical Associations
|
|
Board
Certification:
|
Completing an approved residency program and passing a
rigid examination on that
specialty
|
|
Simply put,
Pathologists that have
accumulated a certain amount of points qualified for the list. This does not
mean that Pathologists that did not accumulate enough points are not good health
care professionals; they merely did not qualify for this list because of the points needed for
qualification.
Similar studies have been done with
other professions using a survey system. This type of study would ask fellow
professionals whom they would recommend. We found this method to be more of a
popularity contest, for instance: professionals who work in a large office have
much more of a chance of being mentioned as opposed to a professional who has a
small private practice. In addition, many professionals have a financial
arrangement for back-and-forth referrals. For these reasons, we developed the
point value system.
Since this is a subjective call,
there is no study that is 100% accurate. As with any profession, there will be
some degree of variance in opinion. If you survey 100 patients from a particular
physician on their satisfaction, you will undoubtedly hear that some are very
satisfied, some moderately satisfied and some dissatisfied. This is really quite
normal.
We feel that a point value system
takes out the personal and emotional factor and deals with factual criteria. We
have made certain assumptions. For example, we feel that the more years in
practice is better than less years in practice; more education is better than
less education, etc.
The Top Pathologists list that we
have compiled is current as of a certain date and other Pathologists may have
qualified since that date. Nonetheless, we feel that the list of Top Pathologists is
a good reference of qualified specialists.
No fees, donations, sponsorships or advertising are accepted from any
individuals, professionals, corporations or associations. This policy is
strictly adhered to, insuring an unbiased selection.
What is Pathology?
from Wikipedia
Pathology (from Greek pathos, feeling, pain or suffering; and
'-ology' signifies 'study of) is the study and diagnosis of disease through examination of organs, tissues, cells and bodily fluids. The
term encompasses both the medical specialty which uses tissues and body fluids to obtain clinically useful information, as well as the related
scientific study of disease processes.
History
The histories of both experimental and medical pathology can be traced to the earliest application of the scientific method to the field of
medicine, a development which occurred in Western Europe during the Italian Renaissance. Most early pathologists were also practicing
physicians or surgeons. Like other medical fields, pathology has become more specialized with time, and most pathologists today do not
practice in other areas of medicine.
Origins of gross pathology
The concept of studying disease through the methodical dissection and examination of diseased bodies, organs, and tissues may seem
obvious today, but there are few if any recorded examples of true autopsies performed prior to the Renaissance. The first physician known
to have repeatedly used anatomic dissection to determine cause of death was an Italian, Antonio Benivieni (1443-1502). Perhaps the most
famous early gross pathologist was Giovanni Morgagni (1682-1771). His magnum opus, De Sedibus et Causis Morborum per Anatomem
Indagatis, published in 1761, describes the findings of over 600 partial and complete autopsies,
organized anatomically and methodically correlated with the symptoms exhibited by the patients prior to their demise. Although the study of
normal anatomy was already well
advanced at this date, De Sedibus was one of the first treatises specifically devoted to the corrolation of diseased anatomy with clinical
illness. By the late 1800's, an exhaustive body of literature had been produced on the gross anatomical findings characteristic of known
diseases. The extent of gross pathology research in this period can be epitomized by the work of the Viennese pathologist Carl Rokitansky
(1804-1878), who is said to have performed 20,000 autopsies, and supervised an additional 60,000, in his lifetime.
Origins of microscopic pathology
The German physician Rudolf Virchow (1821-1902) is generally recognized
to be the father of microscopic pathology. While the compound
microscope had been invented approximately 150 years prior, Virchow was one of the first prominent physicians to emphasize the study of
manifestations of disease which were visible only at the cellular level. A student of Virchow's, Julius Cohnheim (1839-1884) combined
histology techniques with experimental manipulations to study inflammation, making him one of the earliest experimental pathologists.
Cohnheim also pioneered the use of the frozen section; a version of this technique is widely employed by modern pathologists to render
diagnoses and provide other clinical information intraoperatively.
Modern experimental pathology
As new research techniques, such as electron microscopy, immunohistochemistry, and molecular biology have expanded the means by
which biomedical scientists can study disease, the definition and boundaries of investigative pathology have become less distinct. In the
broadest sense, nearly all research which links manifestations of disease to identifiable processes in cells, tissues, or organs can be
considered experimental pathology.
Pathology as a science
Pathology is a broad and complex scientific field which seeks to understand the mechanisms of injury to cells and tissues, as well as the
body's means of responding to and repairing injury. Disease processes may be incited or exacerbated by a variety of external and internal
influences, including trauma, infection, poisoning, loss of blood flow, autoimmunity, inherited or acquired genetic damage, or errors of
development. One common theme in pathology is the way in which the body's responses to injury, while evolved to protect health, can also
contribute in some ways to disease processes. Elucidation of general principles underlying pathologic processes, such as cellular adaptation
to injury, cell death, inflammation, tissue repair, and neoplasia, creates a conceptual framework with which to analyze and understand
specific human diseases.
Adaptation to injury
Cells and tissues may respond to injury and stress by specific mechanisms, which may vary according to the cell types and nature of the
injury. In the short term, cells may activate specific genetic programs to protect their vital proteins and organelles from heat shock or
hypoxia, and may activate DNA repair pathways to fix damage to chromosomes from radiation or chemicals. Hyperplasia is a long-term
adaptive response of cell division and multiplication, which can increase the ability of a tissue to compensate for an injury. For example,
repeated irritation to the skin can cause a protective thickening due to hyperplasia of the epidermis. Hypertrophy is an increase in the size of
cells in a tissue in response to stress, an example being hypertrophy of muscle cells in the heart in response to increased resistance to blood
flow as a result of narrowing of the heart's outflow valve. Metaplasia occurs when repeated damage to the cellular lining of an organ triggers
its replacement by a different cell type.
Cell Death
Necrosis is the irreversible destruction of cells as a result of severe injury in a setting where the cell is unable to activate the needed
metabolic pathways for survival or orderly degeneration. This is often due to external pathologic factors, such as toxins or loss of oxygen
supply. Milder stresses may lead to a process called reversible cell injury, which mimics the cell swelling and vacuolization seen early in the
necrotic process, but in which the cell is able to adapt and survive. In necrosis, the
components of degenerating cells leak out, potentially contributing to inflammation and further damage. Apoptosis, in contrast, is a regulated, orderly
degeneration of the cell which occurs in the
settings of both injury and normal physiological processes.
Inflammation
Inflammation is a particularly important and complex reaction to tissue injury,
and is particularly important in fighting infection. Acute
inflammation is generally a non-specific response triggered by the injured tissue cells themselves, as well as specialized cells of the innate
immune system and previously developed adaptive immune mechanisms. A localized acute inflammatory response triggers vascular
changes in the injured area, recruits pathogen-fighting neutrophils, and begins the process of developing a new adaptive immune response.
Chronic inflammation occurs when the acute response fails to entirely clear the inciting factor. While chronic inflammation can lay a positive
role in containing a continuing infectious hazard, it can also lead to progressive tissue damage, as well as predisposing (in some cases) to
the development of cancer.
Tissue repair
Tissue repair, as seen in wound healing, is triggered by inflammation. The process may proceed even before the resolution of a
precipitating insult, through the formation of granulation tissue. Healing involves the proliferation of connective tissue cells and blood
vessel-forming cells as a result of hormonal growth signals. While healing is a critical adaptive response, an aberrant healing response can
lead to progressive fibrosis, contractures, or other changes which can compromise function.
Neoplasia
Neoplasia, or "new growth," is a proliferation of cells which is independent of any physiological process. The most familiar examples of
neoplasia are benign tumors and cancers. Neoplasia results from genetic changes which cause cells to activate genetic programs
inappropriately. Dysplasia is an early sign of a neoplastic process in a tissue, and is marked by
persistence of immature, poorly differentiated cell forms. Interestingly, there are many similarities in the gene pathways activated in cancer cells, and those activated in cells
involved in wound healing and inflammation.
Pathology as a medical specialty
Physicians who practice pathology diagnose and characterize disease in living patients by examining biopsies and other specimens. For
example, the vast majority of cancer diagnoses are made or confirmed by a pathologist. Pathologists may also conduct autopsies to
investigate causes of death. The medical practice of pathology grew out the tradition of investigative pathology, and many of the academic
leaders in pathology today are accomplished in both basic science research and diagnostic practice. However, as with other specialties in
medicine, most modern physician-pathologists are employed in full-time practice, and do not perform original research.
Pathology is a unique medical specialty in that pathologists typically do not see patients directly, but rather serve as consultants to other
physicians (often referred to as "clinicians" within the pathology community). However, in the United States and in many other countries,
pathologists receive the same doctorate training, and undergo the same medical licensure process as other physicians. Pathology is a
diverse field, and the organization of subspecialties within pathology vary between nations.
Anatomical Pathology
This mastectomy specimen contains an infiltrating ductal carcinoma of the breast. A pathologist will use immunohistochemistry and
fluorescent in-situ hybridization to detect markers which determine the optimal chemotherapy regimen for this patient.
This mastectomy specimen contains an infiltrating ductal carcinoma of the breast. A pathologist will use immunohistochemistry and
fluorescent in-situ hybridization to detect markers which determine the optimal chemotherapy regimen for this patient.
Anatomical pathologists diagnose disease and gain other clinically significant information through the examination of tissues and cells.
This generally involves gross and microscopic visual examination of tissues, with special stains and immunohistochemistry employed to
visualize specific proteins and other substances in and around cells. More recently, anatomical pathologists have begun to employ molecular
biology techniques to gain additional clinical information from these same specimens. Anatomic pathologists serve as the definitive
diagnosticians for most cancers, as well as numerous other diseases.
| |
 |
Surgical pathology is the most significant and time-consuming area of practice for most anatomical pathologists. Surgical pathology
involves the gross and microscopic examination of surgical specimens, as well as biopsies submitted by non-surgeons such as general
internists, medical subspecialists, dermatologists, and interventional radiologists.
|
|
|
Cytopathology is concerned with the microscopic examination of whole, individual cells obtained
from smears or fine needle aspirates.
|
|
|
Molecular pathology refers to the use of nucleic acid-based techniques, such as in-situ hybridization,
reverse-transcriptase polymerase
chain reaction, and nucleic acid microarrays for specialized diagnostic studies of disease in tissues and cells.
Molecular pathology shares some aspects of practice with both anatomic and clinical
pathology, and is sometimes considered a "crossover" discipline.
|
|
|
Autopsies are used to provide definitive evidence of the disease processes contributing to a person's death.
|
|
|
Forensic pathologists receive specialized training in determining the cause of death and other legally relevant
information from the bodies
of persons who died in a non-medical or potentially criminal circumstances.
|
Clinical pathology
Clinical pathology, also known as laboratory medicine, is the medical specialty concerned with diagnosing diseases based on the analysis of
body fluids, such as plasma, urine, stool, respiratory or mucosal secretions, inflammatory exudates, and pleural, pericardial, peritoneal,
synovial, or cerebrospinal fluid. The practice of clinical pathology is centered around the clinical laboratory. In modern clinical laboratories,
many routine studies are largely automated. The clinical pathologist is responsible for overseeing the work of laboratory technicians,
performing quality assurance to assure the validity of test results, performing interpretations of more complex studies, and serving as a
consultant to clinicians so that the most appropriate studies can be performed for the diagnosis or assessment of an individual patient's
condition. In some areas, non-pathologists, such as other physicians or Ph.D.'s may run clinical labs and perform functions within those
specific labs which are similar to the role of a board-certified clinical pathologist.
Sub-specialties within clinical pathology include the following:
| |
|
Clinical chemistry (A board-certifiable subspecialty, chemical pathology, in the U.S.)
|
|
|
Hematology and Flow cytometry (Part of a board-certifiable subspecialty, hematology, in the U.S.)
|
|
|
Blood banking/Transfusion medicine (A board-certifiable subspecialty in the U.S.)
|
|
|
Medical microbiology (A board-certifiable subspecialty in the U.S.)
|
|
|
Medical cytogenetics
|
|
|
Immunology
|
|
|
Molecular genetic pathology (A board-certifiable subspecialty in the U.S.)
|
Dental pathology
In the United States, subspecialty-trained doctors of dental surgery (D.D.S), rather than medical doctors, can be certified by a professional
board to practice dental pathology.
Pathology in the United States
In the United States, pathologists are medical doctors (M.D.) or doctors of osteopathic medicine (D.O.), that have completed a four-year undergraduate
program, four years of medical school training, and three to four years of postgraduate training in the form of a pathology residency. Training may be within two primary
specialties, as recognized by the American Board of Pathology: Anatomic Pathology, and Clinical Pathology, each of which requires separate board certification. Many
pathologists seek a broad-based training and become certified in both fields. These skills are complementary in many hospital-based private practice settings, since the
day-to-day work of many clinical laboratories only requires the intermittent attention of a physician. Thus, pathologists are able to spend much of their time
evaluating
anatomic pathology cases, while remaining available to cover any special issues which might arise in the clinical laboratories. Pathologists may pursue specialized
fellowship training within one or more sub-specialties of either anatomic or clinical pathology. Some of these sub-specialities permit additional board certification,
while others do not
What does a Pathologist
Do?
Histopathology is the diagnosis of disease by studying tissue samples (histology). These range from tiny biopsies (for instance, from
someone's stomach taken by endoscopy) to organs removed at an operation (e.g. a colon containing a cancer). From these specimens,
areas are selected to take sections from, which are stained and examined under a microscope.
This is the major part of the pathologist's job. They are the people who tell other doctors what disease their patient has, whether it is benign
(nice) or malignant (nasty), and whether or not it is out. Very few diagnoses of cancer are made without
their help, and they play an essential role in deciding the correct treatment for an individual patient.
Cytology is the diagnosis of disease from individual cells, such as cervical smears or fluid from cysts. This is much faster to perform than
histology, but has more limited diagnostic abilities: generally, cytology is used as a rapid screening test to determine whether something is
malignant or not, with further biopsy being used to get a definitive, histological diagnosis.
Cytopathology is a branch of pathology that studies and diagnoses diseases on the cellular level. The most common use of cytopathology is
the Pap smear, used to detect cervical cancer at an early treatable stage.
Two methods of collecting cells for analysis are:
| |
1.
|
Exfoliative Cytology – Cells are extracted from fluid shed into the body
cavities. For example, in pleural fluid,
ascitic fluid, or in the case
of the Pap smear, cells scraped from the cervix.
|
|
2.
|
Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology or
Needle aspiration biopsy – An 18 to 27 gauge (most commonly 23-25) needle attached to a 10 cc
syringe is used to aspirate (pull out) cells from lesions or masses in various organs of the body by application of negative pressure
(suction). FNAC can be done directly on a mass in superficial regions like the neck, thyroid or breast; or it maybe be assisted by ultrasound
or CAT scan. FNAC, while poorly developed in the USA, is widely used in Europe and India. Being a skill dependent procedure, the success
rate may vary. If performed by pathologist or as team with pathologist-cytotechnologist, the success rate of proper diagnosis is superior.
The two countries with the most advanced FNAC services are Sweden (Karolinska hospital performs about 11 thousand annual aspirates),
and Slovenia (Institute of Oncology performs about 10 thousand annual aspirates). The highest volumes in USA are encountered at Emory
University Hospital in Atlanta GA, and MD Anderson Hospital in Houston, TX, each contributing no more than 4 thousand aspirates per
year.
|
Equipment
Fine needles are 23 to 27 gauge. Needle diameters and color codes for 23G, 25G and 27G are as follows, respectively: 0,6 mm/Blue-dark,
0,5 mm/Orange, and 0,4 mm/Grey. If a cell-block preparation is indicated, after obtaining diagnostic cytology smears, a wider gauge
needle, up to 18 gauge, may be used.
Autopsies
Autopsies are performed in two situations: at the request of clinicians (with relatives' consent) to determine the cause of death, and to see
whether the correct diagnosis was made in life and the appropriate treatment given, and at the request of the Coroner, if a death is
suspicious or the cause cannot be ascertained (for instance, the deceased had not recently been seen by a doctor). The second case is by far
the more common these days.
Pap smear
In gynecology, the Papanikolaou test or Papanicolaou test (also called Pap
smear, Pap test, cervical smear, or smear test) is a medical
screening method, invented by Georgios Papanikolaou, primarily designed to detect premalignant and malignant processes in the
ectocervix. It may also detect infections and abnormalities in the endocervix and endometrium.
The endocervix may be partially sampled with the device used to obtain the ectocervical sample, but due to the anatomy of this area,
consistent and reliable sampling cannot be guaranteed. As abnormal endocervical cells may be sampled, those examining them are taught
to recognize them. The endometrium is not directly sampled with the device used to sample the ectocervix. Cells may exfoliate onto the cervix and be collected
from there, so as with endocervical cells, abnormal cells can be recognized if present but the Pap Test should not be used as a screening
tool for endometrial malignancy.
The pre-cancerous changes (called dysplasias or cervical or endocervical
intraepithelial neoplasia) are usually caused by sexually transmitted
human papillomaviruses (HPVs). The test aims to detect and prevent the progression of HPV-induced cervical cancer and other
abnormalities in the female genital tract by sampling cells from the outer opening of the cervix (Latin for "neck") of the uterus and the
endocervix.
The sampling technique changed very little since its invention by Georgios Papanikolaou (1883–1962) to detect cyclic hormonal
changes in vaginal cells in the early 20th century until the development of liquid based cell thin layer technology. The test remains an
effective, widely used method for early detection of cervical cancer and pre-cancer. The UK's call and recall system is among the best;
estimates of its effectiveness vary widely but it may prevent about 700 deaths per year in the UK. It is not a perfect test. "A nurse
performing 200 tests each year would prevent a death once in 38 years. During this time she or he would care for over 152 women with
abnormal results, over 79 women would be referred for investigation, over 53 would have abnormal biopsy results, and over 17 would
have persisting abnormalities for more than two years. At least one woman during the 38 years would die from cervical cancer despite
being screened." HPV vaccine may offer better prospects in the long term.
It is generally recommended that sexually active females seek Pap smear testing annually, although guidelines may vary from country to
country. If results are abnormal, and depending on the nature of the abnormality, the test may need to be repeated in three to twelve
months. If the abnormality requires closer scrutiny, the patient may be referred for detailed inspection of the cervix by colposcopy. The
patient may also be referred for HPV DNA testing, which can serve as an adjunct (or even as an alternative) to Pap testing.
About 5% to 7% of pap smears produce abnormal results, such as dysplasia, possibly indicating a pre-cancerous condition. Although many
low grade cervical dysplasias spontaneously regress without ever leading to cervical cancer, dysplasia can serve as an indication that
increased vigilance is needed. Endocervical and endometrial abnormalities can also be detected, as can a number of infectious processes,
including yeast and Trichomonas vaginalis. A small proportion of abnormalities are reported as of "uncertain significance".
Technical aspects
Samples are collected from the outer opening or os of the cervix using an Aylesbury spatula or (more frequently with the advent of
liquid-based cytology) a plastic-fronded broom. The cells are placed on a glass slide and checked for abnormalities in the laboratory.
The sample is stained using the Papanicolaou technique, in which tinctorial dyes and acids are selectively retained by cells. Unstained cells
can not be visualized with light microscopy. The stains chosen by Papanicolau were selected to highlight cytoplasmic keratinization, which
actually has almost nothing to do with the nuclear features used to make diagnoses now.
The sample is then screened by a specially trained and qualified cytotechnologist using a light microscope. The terminology for who screens
the sample varies according the country; in the UK, the personnel are known as Cytoscreeners, Biomedical scientists (BMS), Advanced
Practitioners and Pathologists. The latter two take responsibility for reporting the abnormal sample which may require further investigation.
In the United States, physicians who fail to diagnose cervical cancer from a pap smear have been convicted of negligent homicide. In 1988
and 1989, Karen Smith had received pap smears which were argued to have "unequivocally" shown that she had cancer; yet the lab had not
made the diagnosis. She died on March 8, 1995. Later, a physician and a laboratory technician were convicted of negligent homicide. These
events have led to even more rigorous quality assurance programs, and to emphasizing that this is a screening, not a diagnostic, test,
associated with a small irreducible error rate.
Liquid based monolayer cytology
Since the mid-1990s, techniques based around placing the sample into a vial containing a liquid medium which preserves the cells have
been increasingly used. The media are primarily ethanol based. Two of the types are Sure-Path (TriPath Imaging) and Thin-Prep (Cytyc
Corp). Once placed into the vial, the sample is processed at the laboratory into a cell thin-layer, stained, and examined by light microscopy.
The liquid sample has the advantage of being suitable for low and high risk HPV testing and reduced unsatisfactory specimens from 4.1%
to 2.6%. Proper sample acquisition is crucial to the accuracy of the test; clearly, a cell that is not in the sample cannot be evaluated.
Human papillomavirus testing
The presence of HPV indicates that the person has been infected, the majority of women who get infected will successfully clear the
infection within 18 months. It is those who have an infection of prolonged duration with high risk
types (e.g. types 16,18,33,35) that are more likely to develop Cervical Intraepithelial Neoplasia due to the effects that HPV has on DNA.
By adding the more sensitive HPV test, the specificity may decline. However, the drop in specificity is not definite. If the specificity does
decline, this results in increased numbers of false positive tests and many women who did not have disease having colposcopy and
treatment. A worthwhile screening test requires a balance between the sensitivity and specificity to ensure that those having a disease are
correctly identified as having it and equally importantly those not identifying those without the disease as having it. Due to the liquid based
pap smears having a false negative rate of 15-35%, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists citation needed] and American
Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology have recommended the use of HPV testing in addition to the pap smear in all women over
the age of 30.
Regarding the role of HPV testing, randomized controlled trials have compared HPV to colposcopy. HPV testing appears as sensitive as
immediate colposcopy while reducing the number of colposcopies needed. Randomized controlled trial have suggested that HPV testing
could follow abnormal cytology or could precede cervical cytology examination.
A study published in April 2007 suggested the act of performing a Pap smear produces an inflammatory cytokine response, which may
initiate immunologic clearance of HPV, therefore reducing the risk of cervical cancer. Women who had even a single Pap smear in their
history had a lower incidence of cancer. "A statistically significant decline in the HPV positivity rate correlated with the lifetime number of
Pap smears received."
Automated analysis
In the last decade there have been successful attempts to develop automated, computer image analysis systems for
screening.
Automation may improve sensitivity and reduce unsatisfactory specimens. One of these has been FDA approved and functions in high
volume reference laboratories, with human oversight.
Practical aspects
The physician or operator collecting a sample for the test inserts a speculum into the patient's vagina, to obtain a cell sample from the
cervix. A pap smear appointment is normally not scheduled during menstruation, and patients should avoid contamination of the vagina
and uterus (for example by a douche) before the exam, to avoid false results. The procedure is usually just slightly painful, because of the
neuroanatomy of the cervix. However, this can depend on the patient's anatomy, the skill of the practitioner, psychological factors, and
other conditions. Results usually take about 3 weeks. Slight bleeding, cramps, and other discomfort can occur afterwards.
Anatomical Pathology
Anatomical pathology (Commonwealth) or Anatomic pathology (U.S.) is a medical specialty that is concerned with the diagnosis of disease
based on the gross, microscopic, and molecular examination of organs, tissues, and cells. In many countries, physicians who practice
pathology are trained in both anatomical pathology and clinical pathology, the diagnosis of disease through the laboratory analysis of bodily
fluids.
Anatomical pathologists diagnose disease and gain other clinically significant information through the examination of tissues and cells. This
generally involves gross and microscopic visual examination of tissues, with special stains and immunohistochemistry employed to visualize
specific proteins and other substances in and around cells. More recently, anatomical pathologists have begun to employ molecular biology
techniques to gain additional clinical information from these same specimens.
Skills and procedures
The procedures used in anatomic pathology include:
| |
|
Gross examination - the examination of diseased tissues with the naked eye. This is important especially for large tissue fragments,
because the disease can often be visually identified. It is also at this step that the pathologist selects areas that will be processed for
histopathology.
|

|
|
|
Histopathology - the microscopic examination of stained tissue
sections using histological techniques. The standard stains are
haematoxylin and eosin, but many others exist. The use of haematoxylin and eosin-stained slides to provide specific diagnoses based on
morphology is considered to be the core skill of anatomic pathology. The science of staining tissues sections is called
histochemistry.
|
|
|
Immunohistochemistry
- The use of antibodies to detect the presence, abundance, and localization of specific proteins. This technique
is critical to distinguishing between disorders with similar morphology, as well as characterizing the molecular properties of certain cancers.
|
|
|
In situ hybridization - Specific DNA and RNA molecules can be identified
on sections using this technique. When the probe is labeled
with fluorescent dye, the technique is called FISH.
|
|
|
Cytopathology
- the examination of loose cells spread and stained on glass slides using cytology techniques.
|
|
|
Electron microscopy - the examination of tissue with an electron
microscope, which allows much greater magnification, enabling the
visualization of organelles within the cells. Its use has been largely supplanted by
immunhistochemistry, but it is still in common use for certain tasks, including the diagnosis of kidney disease and the identification of immotile cilia syndrome among
many others.
|
|
|
Tissue cytogenetics - the visualization of chromosomes to identify
genetics defects such as chromosomal translocation.
|
|
|
Flow immunophenotyping - the determination of the immunophenotype
of cells using flow cytometry techniques. It is very useful to
diagnose the different types of leukemia and lymphoma.
|
Subdisciplines
This surgically removed segment of colon contains a suspicious polyp. An anatomical pathologist will look for invasive cancer and determine
the extend of its spread. This surgically removed segment of colon contains a suspicious polyp. An anatomical pathologist will look for invasive cancer and determine
the extend of its spread.
Surgical pathology
 Surgical pathology is the most significant and time-consuming area of practice for most anatomical
pathologists. Surgical pathology involves
the gross and microscopic examination of surgical specimens, as well as biopsies submitted by non-surgeons such as general internists,
medical subspecialists, dermatologists, and interventional radiologists.
Cytopathology
Cytopathology is a sub-discipline of anatomical pathology concerned with the microscopic examination of whole, individual cells obtained
from smears or fine needle aspirates. Cytopathologists are trained to perform fine-needle aspirates of superficially located organs, masses,
or cysts, and are often able to render an immediate diagnosis in the presence of the patient and consulting physician. In the case of
screening tests such as the Papanicolaou smear, non-physician cytotechnologists are often employed to perform initial reviews, with only
positive or uncertain cases examined by the pathologist. Cytopathology is a board-certifiable subspecialty in the U.S.
Molecular Pathology
Molecular pathology is an emerging discipline within anatomical pathology which is focused on the use of nucleic acid-based techniques
such as in-situ hybridization, reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction, and nucleic acid microarrays for
specialized studies of disease
in tissues and cells. Molecular pathology shares some aspects of practice with both anatomic and clinical pathology, and is sometimes
considered a "crossover" discipline.
Autopsy pathology
General anatomical pathologists are trained in performing autopsies, which are used to determine the disease factors contributing to a
person's death. Autopsies are important in the ongoing medical education of clinicians, and in efforts to improve and verify the quality of
medical care. Deniers are non-physicians who assist pathologists in the gross dissection portion of the autopsy. Autopsies represent less
than 10% of the workload of typical pathologists in the United States. However, the autopsy is central to public perceptions of the field, in
part due to portrayals of pathologists on television programs such as Quincy, M.E. and Silent Witness.
Forensic pathology
Forensic pathologists receive specialized training in determining the cause of death and other legally relevant information from the bodies of
persons who died in a non-medical or potentially criminal circumstances. Autopsies make up much, but not all of the work of the practicing
forensic pathologist, and forensic pathologists are occasionally consulted to examine a survivor of a criminal attack. Forensic pathology is a
board-certifiable sub-specialty in the U.S.
Training and certification of Anatomical Pathologists
Anatomic Pathology (AP) is one of the two primary certifications offered by the American Board of Pathology. The other is Clinical
Pathology (CP). To be certified in anatomic pathology, the trainee must complete four years of medical school followed by three years of
residency training. Many US pathologists are certified in both AP and CP, which requires a total of four years of residency. After completing
residency, many pathologists enroll in further years of fellowship training to gain expertise in a subspecialty of AP.
Canada
Anatomical Pathology (AP) is one of the specialist certificates granted by the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Other
certificates related to pathology include general pathology (GP), forensic pathology, hematopathology, and neuropathology. Candidates for
any of these must have completed four years of medical school and five years of residency training. After becoming certified in either AP or
GP, it is common for pathologists to seek further fellowship training in a subspecialty of AP.
Anatomical pathology practice settings
| |
|
Academic anatomical pathology is practiced by pathologists who are also faculty members of a university
medical center often have a
diverse set of responsibilities, such are practicing diagnostic anatomical pathology, conducting basic or translational research, training
pathology residents, and teaching medical students. Anatomical pathologists in the academic setting are often more specialized in a specific
area of expertise, than their private-practice counterparts.
|
|
|
Group practice is the most traditional private practice model. In this arrangement, a group of senior pathologists
will control a
partnership which employs more junior pathologists, and which contracts independently
with hospitals to provide diagnostic services, as well as attracting referral business from local clinicians who practice in the outpatient setting. The group often owns a
lab for histology and
ancillary testing of tissue, and may hold contracts to run hospital-owned labs. Many pathologists who practice in this setting are
trained and certified in both anatomical pathology and clinical pathology, which allows them to blood banks, clinical chemistry laboratories, and medical
microbiology laboratories as well.
|
|
|
Large corporate providers of anatomical pathology services have emerged in recent years, most notably
AmeriPath in the United States.
In this model, pathologists are employees, rather than independent partners. This model has been
criticized for reducing physician independence, but defenders claim that the larger size of these practices allow for economies of scale and greater specialization, as well a
sufficient volume to support more specialized testing methods.
|
|
|
Multispecialty groups, composed of physicians from clinical specialties as well as radiology and pathology, are
another practice model.
In some case, these may be large groups controlled by an HMO or other large health care organization. In others, they are essentially
clinician group practices which employ pathologists to provide diagnostic services for the group. These groups may own their own
laboratories, or, in some cases have made controversial arrangements with "pod labs" which allow clinician groups to lease space, with the
clinician groups receiving direct insurance payments for pathology
services. Proposed changes to Medicare regulations may essentially eliminate these arrangements in the United States.
|
Surgical Pathology
Surgical pathology is the most significant and time-consuming area of practice for most anatomical pathologists. Surgical pathology involves
the gross and microscopic examination of surgical specimens, as well as biopsies submitted by non-surgeons such as general internists,
medical subspecialists, dermatologists, and interventional radiologists. Generally
recognized sub-specialties of surgical pathology include the following:
The practice of surgical pathology allows for definitive diagnosis of disease (or lack thereof) in any case
where tissue is surgically removed from a patient. This is usually performed by a combination of gross
(i.e., macroscopic) and histologic (i.e., microscopic) examination of the
tissue, and may involve evaluations of molecular properties of the tissue by immunohistochemistry or other laboratory tests.
Specimens
There are two major types of specimens submitted for surgical pathology analysis, biopsies, and surgical resections.
A biopsy is a small piece of tissue removed primarily for the purposes of surgical pathology analysis, most often in order to render a
definitive diagnosis. Types of biopsies include core biopsies which are obtained through the use of large-bore needles, sometimes under the
guidance of radiological techniques such as ultrasound, CT scan, or magnetic resonance imaging. Core biopsies, which preserve tissue
architecture, should not be confuse with fine needle aspiration specimens, which are analyzed using cytopathology techniques. Incisional
biopsies are obtained through diagnostic surgical procedures which remove part of a suspicious lesion, while excisional biopsies remove the
entire lesion, and are similar to as therapeutic surgical resections. Excisional biopsies of skin lesions and gastrointestinal polyps are very
common.
The pathologist's interpretation of a biopsy is critical to establishing the diagnosis of a benign or malignant tumor, and can
differentiate between different types and grades of cancer, as well as determining the activity of specific molecular pathways in the tumor.
This information is important for estimating the patient's prognosis and for choosing the best treatment to administer. Biopsies are also
used to diagnose diseases other than cancer, including inflammatory, infectious, or idiopathic diseases of the skin and gastrointestinal tract,
to name only a few.
Surgical resection specimens are produced through the therapeutic removal of an entire diseased area or organ (and occasionally multiple
organs). These procedures are often intended as definitive surgical treatment of a disease in which the diagnosis is already known or
strongly suspected. However, pathological analysis of these specimens is critically important in confirming the previous diagnosis, staging
the extent of malignant disease, establishing whether or not the entire diseased area was removed (sometimes intraoperatively through the
technique of frozen section), identifying the presence of unsuspected concurrent diseases, and providing information for postoperative
treatment, such as adjuvant chemotherapy in the case of cancer.
Surgical pathology workflow
| |
|
Gross examination
|
|
|
Frozen section
|
|
|
Fixation & Embedding
|
|
|
Histopathologic examination
|
|
|
Ancillary testing
|
|
|
The surgical pathology report
|
|
|
Direct consultation
|
Subspecialties
Many pathologists seek fellowship-level training, or otherwise pursue expertise in a focused area of surgical pathology. Subspecialization is
particularly prevalent in the academic setting, where pathologists may specialize
in an area of diagnostic surgical pathology which is relevant to their research, but is becoming increasingly prevalent in private practice as well. Subspecialization
has a number of benefits, such as
allowing for increased experience and skill at interpreting challenging cases, as well as development of a closer working relationship between
the pathologist and clinicians within a subspecialty area. Commonly recognized subspecialties of surgical pathology include the following:
| |
|
Bone pathology
|
|
|
Cardiac pathology
|
|
|
Dermatopathology
(A board-certifiable subspecialty in the U.S.)
|
|
|
Endocrine pathology
|
|
|
Gastrointestinal pathology
|
|
|
Genitourinary pathology
|
|
|
Gynecologic pathology
|
|
|
Head and Neck Pathology
|
|
|
Hematopathology
(Part of a board-certifiable subspecialty, Hematology, in the U.S.)
|
|
|
Neuropathology
(A board-certifiable subspecialty in the U.S. and a
recognized specialty in the U.K.)
|
|
|
Ophthalmic pathology
|
|
|
Pediatric pathology
(A board-certifiable subspecialty in the U.S. and a
recognized specialty in the U.K.)
|
|
|
Pulmonary pathology
|
|
|
Renal pathology
|
|
|
Soft tissue pathology
|
Autopsy
An autopsy, also known as a post-mortem examination, necropsy, or obduction, is a medical procedure that
consists of a thorough examination of a corpse to determine the cause and manner of death and to evaluate any disease or injury that may be present. It is
usually performed by a specialized medical doctor called a pathologist.
Autopsies are either performed for legal or medical purposes. A forensic autopsy is carried out when the cause of death
may be a criminal matter, while a clinical or academic autopsy is performed to find the medical cause of death and is used in cases of unknown or uncertain death,
or for research purposes. Autopsies can be further classified into cases where external examination suffices, and those where the body is dissected and an internal
examination is conducted. Permission from next of kin may be required for internal autopsy in some cases. Once an internal autopsy is complete the body is reconstituted
by sewing it back together.
Necropsy is the term for a post-mortem examination performed on an animal. The prefix 'auto-' means 'self', and so autopsy denotes
the human species performing a post-mortem examination on one of its own.
Role of autopsy in medicine
Autopsies are important in clinical medicine as they often shed light on mistakes and can be used to help guide continuous improvement.
A study that focused on myocardial infarction (heart attack) as a cause of death found significant errors of omission and
commission, i.e., a sizable number cases ascribed to myocardial infarctions (MIs) were not MIs and a significant number of non-MIs were actually MIs.
A large meta-analysis suggested that approximately one third of death certificates are incorrect and that half of the autopsies performed
produced findings that were not suspected before the person
died. Also, it is thought that over one fifth of unexpected findings can only be diagnosed histologically, i.e. by biopsy or autopsy, and that approximately one quarter of
unexpected findings, or 5% of all findings, are major and can similarily only be diagnosed from tissue.
General information
The term "autopsy" derives from the Greek for "to see for oneself". "Necropsy" is from the Greek for "seeing a dead body".
There are three main types of autopsies:
| |
|
Forensic: This is done for medical-legal purposes, and is the one that is normally seen on television or in
the news. This type depict an extensive methodology and tends to be complete and comprehensive. No family permission is required to complete this type of
autopsy. |
|
|
Clinical/Academic: This is usually performed in hospitals to determine a cause of death for research and
study purposes. This usually is as comprehensive as it needs to be adequate. Most hospitals' deaths requiring an autopsy fall under this category. To complete this type of
autopsy, permission from the deceased's legal next of kin is required. |
|
|
Coroner's:
In Great Britain this type of autopsy encompasses cases with no clear natural cause of death.
Cause, manner and mechanism of death are in question. Eventually, the
prosecutors will identify whether the cases deserve comprehensive forensic autopsy or a routine postmortem. In the United States, each state has a set of guidelines
defining a "Coroner's Case" for autopsy, for example: hospital deaths occurring within 24 hours of admission or within 24 hours of a major surgical procedure, with any
history (current or remote) of illegal drug or alcohol abuse by the deceased, patients with certain communicable diseases (HIV, Hepatitis C Virus, etc.), patient's with
any previous history of violent injury (e.g., gunshot wound many years before death). These cases may or may not be also considered "Forensic" in nature. They may
be done by the hospital pathologist with the legal permission of the Coroner or Medical Examiner for that county/parish and do not require permission from the deceased's
legal next of kin. |
While dissection of human remains for medical reasons has been
practiced irregularly for millennia, the modern autopsy process derives from the anatomists of the Renaissance. The two great nineteenth-century medical researchers Rudolf
Virchow and Carl von Rokitansky built on the Renaissance legacy to derive the two distinct autopsy techniques that still bear their names. Their demonstration of correspondences
between pathological conditions in dead bodies and symptoms and illnesses in the living opened the way for a different way of thinking about disease and its treatment. In China,
the office of coroner and forensic autopsy have a history nearly two thousand years old.
Forensic autopsy
A forensic autopsy is used to determine the cause of death. Forensic science involves the application of the sciences to answer questions
of interest to the legal system. In United States law, deaths are placed in one of five manners:
| |
|
Natural |
|
|
Accident |
|
|
Homicide |
|
|
Suicide |
|
|
Undetermined |
Following an in-depth examination of all the evidence, a medical examiner or coroner will assign a manner of death as one of the
five listed above; and detail the evidence on the mechanism of the death.
Clinical autopsy
Clinical autopsies serve two major purposes. They are performed to gain more insight into pathological processes and determine what
factors contributed to a patient's death. More importantly, autopsies are performed to ensure the standard of care at hospitals. Autopsies can yield insight into how patient
deaths can be prevented in the future.
The process
The body is received at a medical examiner's office or hospital in a body bag or evidence sheet. A brand new body bag is used for each
body to ensure that only evidence from that body is contained within the bag. Evidence sheets are an alternate way to transport the body. An evidence sheet is a sterile sheet
that the body is covered in when it is moved. If it is believed there may be any significant residue on the hands, for instance gunpowder, a separate paper sack is put around each
hand and taped shut around the wrist.
There are two parts to the physical examination of the body: the external and internal examination. Toxicology, biochemical tests and/or
genetic testing often supplement these and frequently assist the pathologist in assigning the cause or causes of death.
External examination
The person responsible for handling, cleaning and moving the body is often called a
Diener, the German word for servant. After the body is received, it is first photographed. The examiner then notes the kind of clothes and their position on the body before they
are removed. Next, any evidence such as residue, flakes of paint or other material is collected from the external surfaces of the body. Ultraviolet light may also be used to search
body surfaces for any evidence not easily visible to the naked eye. Samples of hair, nails and the like are taken, and the body may also be radiographically imaged.
Once the external evidence is collected, the body is removed from the bag, undressed and any wounds present are examined.
The body is then cleaned, weighed and measured in preparation for the internal examination. The scale used to weigh the body is often designed to accommodate the
cart that the body is transported on; its weight is then deducted from the total weight shown to give the weight of the body.
If not already within an autopsy room, the body is transported to one and placed on a table.
A general description of the body as regards race, sex, age, hair color and length, eye color and other distinguishing features (birthmarks, old scar tissue, moles, etc) is then made.
A handheld voice recorder or a standard examination form is normally used to record this information. In some countries e.g. United Kingdom, France, Germany and Canada to name
but a few, an autopsy may comprise an external examination only. This concept is sometimes termed a "view and grant". The principles behind this being that the medical records,
history of the deceased and circumstances of death have all indicated as to the cause and manner of death without the need for an internal examination.
Internal examination
If not already in place, a plastic or rubber brick called a "body block" is placed under the back of the body, causing the arms and neck to
fall backward whilst stretching and pushing the chest upward to make it easier to cut open. This gives the prosector, a pathologist or assistant, maximum exposure to the trunk.
After this is done, the internal examination begins. The internal examination consists of inspecting the internal organs of the body for evidence of trauma or other indications of
the cause of death. For the internal examination there are a number of different approaches available:
| |
|
a large and deep Y-shaped incision can be made from behind each ear and running down the sides of the neck,
meeting at the breastbone. This is the approach most often used in forensic autopsies so as to allow maximum exposure of the neck structures for later detailed examination.
This could prove essential in cases of suspected strangulation |
|
|
a T-shaped incision made from the tips of both shoulder, in a horizontal line across the region of the collar bones to
meet at the sternum (breastbone) in the middle. This initial cut is used more often to produce a more aesthetic finish to the body when it is re-constituted as stitching marks
will not be as apparent as with a Y-shaped incision |
|
|
a single vertical cut is made from the middle of the neck (in the region of the 'Adam's apple' on a male body)
|
In all of the above cases the cut then extends all the way down to the pubic bone (making a deviation to the left side of the navel).
Bleeding from the cuts is minimal, or non-existent, due to the fact that the pull of gravity is producing the only blood pressure at this point,
related directly to the complete lack of cardiac functionality. However, in certain cases there is anecdotal evidence to prove that bleeding can be quite diffuse especially in cases of
drowning.
An electric saw dubbed a "Stryker saw" after a common manufacturer of the tool, is most often used to open the chest cavity. However,
in some cases, due to the large amount of dust created when the bone is cut by the saw, shears are used to open the chest cavity. It is also possible to
utilize a simple scalpel blade. The prosector uses the tool to saw through the ribs on the lateral sides of the chest cavity to allow the sternum and attached ribs to be lifted as one
chest plate; this is done so that the heart and lungs can be seen in situ and that the heart, in particular the pericardial sac is not damaged or disturbed from opening. A scalpel is
used to remove any soft tissue that is still attached to the posterior side of the chest plate. Now the lungs and the heart are exposed. The chest plate is set aside and will be
eventually replaced at the end of the autopsy.
At this stage the organs are exposed. Usually, the organs are removed in a systematic fashion. Making a decision as to what order the
organs are to be removed will depend highly on the case in question. Organs can be removed
individually, in separate blocks or all together in a single block (from the torso).
One method is described here: The pericardial sac is opened to view the heart. Blood for chemical analysis may be removed from the
inferior vena cava or the pulmonary veins. Before removing the heart, the pulmonary artery is opened in order to search for a blood clot. The heart can then be removed by
cutting the inferior vena cava, the pulmonary veins, the aorta and pulmonary artery, and the superior vena cava. This method leaves the aortic arch intact, which will make things
easier for the embalmer. The left lung is then easily accessible and can be removed by cutting the bronchus, artery, and vein at the hilum. The right lung can then be similarly
removed. The abdominal organs can be removed one by one after first examining their relationships and vessels.
Some pathologists, however, prefer to remove the organs all in one "block". Then a series of cuts, along the vertebral column, are made
so that the organs can be detached and pulled out in one piece for further inspection and sampling. During autopsies of infants, this method is used almost all of the time. The
various organs are examined, weighed and tissue samples in the form of slices are taken. Even major blood vessels are cut open and inspected at this stage. Next the stomach
and intestinal contents are examined and weighed. This could be useful to find the cause and time of death, due to the natural passage of food through the bowel during
digestion. The more area empty, the longer the victim had gone without a meal before death.
The body block that was used earlier to elevate the chest cavity is now used to elevate the head. To examine the brain, a cut is made from behind one ear, over the crown
of the head, to a point behind the other ear. When the autopsy is completed, the incision can be neatly sewn up and is not noticed when the head is resting on a pillow in an
open casket funeral. The scalp is pulled away from the skull in two flaps with the front flap going over the face and the rear flap over the back of the neck. The skull is then
cut with an electric saw to create a "cap" that can be pulled off, exposing the brain. The brain is then observed in situ. Then the brain's connection to the spinal cord is severed,
and the brain is then lifted out of the skull for further examination. If the brain needs to be preserved before being inspected, it is contained in a large container of formalin
(15 percent solution of formaldehyde gas in buffered water) for at least two but preferably four weeks. This not only preserves the brain, but also makes it firmer allowing
easier handling without corrupting the tissue.
Reconstitution of the body
An important aim of the autopsy is to reconstitute the body such that it can be viewed, if desired, by relatives of the deceased following
the procedure. After the examination, the body has an open and empty chest cavity with chest flaps open on both sides, the top of the skull is missing, and the skull flaps are
pulled over the face and neck. It is unusual to examine the face, arms, hands or legs internally. The organs are replaced (which are usually poured in) or incinerated, the chest
flaps are closed and sewn back together and the skull cap is sewed back in place. Then the body may be wrapped in a shroud and it is common for relatives of the deceased to
not be able to tell the procedure has been done when the deceased is viewed in a funeral parlor after embalming.
Other information
The principal aim of an autopsy is to discover the cause of death, to determine the state of health of the person before he or she died,
and whether any medical diagnosis and treatment before death was appropriate. Studies have shown that even in the modern era of use of high technology scanning and medical
tests, the medical cause of death is wrong in about one third of instances unless an autopsy is
performed. In about one in ten cases the cause of death is so wrong that had it been known in life the medical management of the patient would have been significantly
different.
In most Western countries the number of autopsies performed in hospitals has been decreasing every year since 1955. Critics, including
pathologist and former JAMA editor George Lundberg, have charged that the reduction in autopsies is negatively affecting the care delivered in hospitals, because when mistakes
result in death, they are often not investigated and lessons learned.
When a person has given permission in advance of their death, autopsies may also be carried out for the purposes of teaching or medical
research.
An autopsy is frequently performed in cases of sudden death, where a doctor is not able to write a death certificate, or when death is
believed to be due to an unnatural cause. These examinations are performed under a legal authority (Medical Examiner or Coroner or Procurator Fiscal) and do not require the
consent of relatives of the deceased. The most extreme example is the examination of murder victims, especially when medical examiners are looking for signs of death or the
murder method, such as bullet wounds and exit points, signs of strangulation, or traces of poison.
Forensic Pathology
Forensic pathology is a branch of medicine concerned with
determining cause of death, usually for criminal law cases and civil law cases in some jurisdictions. The word forensics is derived from the Latin fore-nsis meaning public or forum.
The word pathology literally means study of disease.
The Forensic pathologist:
| |
|
Is a qualified medical doctor who has completed training in anatomical pathology and who has subsequently sub-specialized
in forensic pathology. 'Fully qualified' forensic pathologists are individuals who, for example, are certified by the American Board of Pathology ("board-certified") (United States)
or who are eligible for inclusion on the specialist register of the General Medical Council (GMC) having obtained Membership of the Royal College of Pathologists (United Kingdom).
|
|
|
Performs autopsies/ post mortem examinations to determine the cause of death (such as a bullet wound to the head,
exsanguination, strangulation, etc.) and (in the USA) the 'manner of death' (for example homicide, accident, natural, suicide or undetermined). The autopsy also provides an
opportunity for other issues raised by the death to be addressed, such as the identity of the deceased etc. |
|
|
Examines wounds and injuries. |
|
|
Examines tissue specimens under the microscope histology in order to identify the presence or absence of natural
disease, as well as to determine the 'age' of wounds and injuries etc. |
|
|
Interprets toxicological analyses on bodily tissues and fluids to determine e.g. overdoses or deliberate
poisonings. |
|
|
Forensic pathologists also work closely with the medico-legal authority for the area concerned with the investigation
of sudden and unexpected deaths i.e. the coroner (England and Wales), Procurator Fiscal (Scotland) or Coroner or medical examiner (United States). |
|
|
Serves as an expert witness in courts of law testifying in civil or criminal law cases. |
In an Autopsy, they are often assisted by an autopsy/mortuary technician (sometimes called a Diener in the USA).
Forensic physicians (sometimes referred to as 'Forensic Medical Examiners' or 'Police Surgeons' (in the UK until recently)) are medical doctors trained
in the examination of, and provision of medical treatment to, living victims of assault (including sexual assault) and those individuals who find themselves in police custody.
Many forensic physicians in the UK practice clinical forensic medicine on a part-time basis, whilst they also practice family medicine, or another medical specialty.
Investigation of death
Deaths that are not considered natural are investigated. In some jurisdictions this is done by a coroner and in others by a medical examiner.
Terminology is not consistent across jurisdictions. In some jurisdictions, the title of "Medical Examiner" is used by non-physician, elected officials involved in medicolegal death
investigation. In others, the title is reserved exclusively for physicians that are appointed.
Similarily, the title "Coroner" is applied to both physicians and non-physicians. Historically, coroners were not all physicians. However, in some jurisdictions the title of "Coroner"
is exclusively used by physicians.
Coroners and medical examiner in the US
In the United States, a coroner, typically, is an elected public official, in a particular geographic jurisdiction, who investigates and certifies deaths.
The vast majority of coroners lack a Doctor of Medicine degree and the amount of medical training that they have received is highly variable, depending on their profession
(e.g. law enforcement, judges, funeral directors, firefighters, nurses).
In contrast, a medical examiner, typically, is a physician who holds the degree of Doctor of Medicine. Ideally, a medical examiner has completed
both a pathology residency (medicine) and a fellowship in forensic pathology.
He or she may also be board certified by the American Board of Pathology in Anatomic and Forensic Pathology. This entails passing separate
examinations in anatomic pathology and forensic pathology. To be eligible for the American Board of Pathology's board examinations, a candidate must demonstrate that
he or she has completed training in anatomic pathology and forensic pathology at programs accredited by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education.
History in United States
Forensic pathology was first recognized in the USA by the American Board of Pathology in 1959.
Becoming a forensic pathologist
Forensic pathology is a subspecialty of anatomical pathology and typically one year of additional training (a fellowship), that is completed after
becoming a licensed anatomical pathologist. Becoming an anatomical pathologist requires completing a four or five year residency in anatomical pathology, which is something
one does on completing medical school. In
Canada and UK, anatomical pathology is a five year residency. In the US, anatomic pathology (as it is called), is a four year residency.
In the United States, all told, the education after high school is typically 13 years in duration (4 years undergraduate training + 4 years medical
school + 4 years residency (in anatomical pathology) + 1 year forensic pathology fellowship). Generally, the biggest hurdle is gaining admission to medical school.
Principals of Pathology
Disease
A disease is an abnormal condition of an organism that impairs bodily functions. In human beings, "disease" is often used more broadly to refer to any condition that causes
discomfort, dysfunction, distress, social problems, and/or death to the person afflicted, or similar problems for those in contact with the person. In this broader sense, it sometimes
includes injuries, disabilities, disorders, syndromes, infections, isolated symptoms, deviant behaviors, and atypical variations of structure and function, while in other contexts and for
other purposes these may be considered distinguishable categories. This article primarily describes human diseases, one of man's greatest enemies.
While many diseases are biological processes with observable alterations of organ function or structure, others primarily involve alterations
of behavior.
Classifying a condition as a disease is a social act of valuation, and may change the social status of the person with the condition (the patient). Some
conditions (known as culture-bound syndromes) are only recognized as diseases within a particular culture. Sometimes the categorization of a condition as a disease is controversial
within the culture.
Causes of disease
Many different factors intrinsic or extrinsic to a person (or plant or animal) can cause disease. Examples of intrinsic factors are genetic
defects or nutritional deficiencies. An an environmental exposure, such as second-hand smoke is an example of an extrinsic factor. Many diseases result from a combination of
intrinsic and extrinsic factors. For many diseases a cause cannot be identified.
There are many different factors that can cause disease. These can be broadly categorized into the following categories like social,
psychological, chemical and biological. Some factors may fall into more than one category. Biochemical causes of disease can be considered as a spectrum where at one extreme
disease is caused entirely by genetic factors (e.g. CAG repeats in the Huntingtin gene that causes Huntington's Disease) and at the other extreme is caused entirely by
environmental factors. Environmental factors include toxic chemicals (e.g. acetaldehyde in cigarette smoke and dioxins released from the breakdown of Agent Orange) and
infectious agents (e.g. smallpox virus and poliovirus). In between these extremes genes (e.g. NOD2/CARD15) and environmental factors (e.g. Gut microbiota) interact to cause
disease, as seen for example in the inflammatory bowel disease Crohn's Disease (Fig 1, right).
Absence of the genetic or environmental factors in this case results in disease not being manifest. Koch's postulates can be used to determine whether a
disease is caused by an infectious agent.
To determine whether a disease is caused by genetic factors, researchers study the pattern inheritance of the disease in families. This
provides qualitative information about the disease (how it is inherited). A classic example of this method of research is inheritance of hemophilia in the British Royal Family. More
recently this research has been used to identify the Apoliprotein E (ApoE) gene as a susceptibility gene for Alzheimer's Disease, though some forms of this gene - ApoE2 - are
associated with a lower susceptibility.
To determine to what extent a disease is caused by genetic factors (quantitative information), twin studies are used. Monozygotic twins
are genetically identical and likely share a similar environment whereas dizygotic twins are genetically similar and likely share a similar environment. Thus by comparing the incidence
of disease (termed concordance rate) in monozygotic twins with the incidence of disease in dizygotic twins, the extent to which genes contribute to disease can be determined.
Candidate disease genes can be identified using a number of methods. One is to look for mutants of a model organism (e.g. the organisms Mus
musculus, Drosophila melanogaster, Caenhorhabditis elegans, Brachydanio rerio and Xenopus tropicalis) that have a similar phenotype to the disease being studied. Another
approach is to look for segregation of genes or genetic markers (e.g. single nucleotide polymorphism or expressed sequence tag)
A large number of SNPs spaced throughout the genome have been identified recently in a large project called the HapMap project. The
usefulness of the HapMap project and SNP typing and their relevance to society was covered in the 27th October 2005 issue of the leading international science journal Nature
(journal).
A large number of genes have been identified that contribute to human disease. These are available from the US National Library of
Medicine, which has an impressive range of biological science resources available for free online. Amongst these resources is Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man - OMIM that
provides a very, very comprehensive list of all known human gene mutations associated with, and likely contributing to, disease. Each article at OMIM is regularly updated to include
the latest scientific research. Additionally, each article provides a detailed history of the research on a given disease gene, with links to the research articles. This resource is highly
valuable and is used by the world's top science researchers.
The terms disease, disorder, medical condition are often used interchangeably. There is no agreed-upon universal distinction between
these terms, though some people do make distinctions in particular contexts.
Medical usage sometimes distinguishes a disease, which has a known specific cause or causes (called its etiology), from a syndrome, which
is a collection of signs or symptoms that occur together. However, many conditions have been identified, yet continue to be referred to as "syndromes." Furthermore, numerous
conditions of unknown etiology are referred to as "diseases" in many contexts. Refractory diseases do not respond to therapy by overcoming the resistance to drugs.
Illness, although often used to mean disease, can also refer to a person's perception of their health, regardless of whether they in fact
have a disease. A person without any disease may feel unhealthy and simply have the perception of having an illness. Another person may feel healthy with similar perceptions
of perfectly good health. The individual's perception of good health may even persist with the medical diagnosis of having a disease; for example, such as dangerously high blood
pressure, which may lead to a fatal heart attack or stroke.
Pathology is the study of diseases. The subject of systematic classification of diseases is referred to as nosology. The broader body of
knowledge about human diseases and their treatments is medicine. Many similar (and a few of the same) conditions or processes can affect non-human animals (wild or domestic).
The study of diseases affecting animals is veterinary medicine.
Disease can be thought of as the presence of pathology, which can occur with or without subjective feelings of being unwell or social
recognition of that state. Illness as the subjective state of "unwellness" can occur independently of, or in conjunction with, disease or sickness (with sickness the social
classification of someone deemed diseased, which can also occur independently of the presence or absence of disease or illness (c.f. subjective medical conditions). Thus,
someone with undetected high blood pressure who feels to be of good health would be diseased, but not ill or sick. Someone with a diagnosis of late-stage cancer would be
diseased, probably feeling quite ill, and recognized by others as sick. A person incarcerated in a totalitarian psychiatric hospital for political purposes could arguably be then said to
not be diseased, nor ill, but only classified as sick by the rulers of a society with which the person did not agree. Having had a bad day after a night of excess drinking, one might
feel ill, but one would not be diseased, nor is it likely that a boss could be convinced of the sickness.
Transmission of disease
Some diseases such as influenza are contagious or infectious. Infectious diseases can be transmitted by any of a variety of mechanisms,
including aerosols produced by coughs and sneezes, by bites of insects or other carriers of the disease, and from contaminated water or food (possibly by
feces or urine in the
sewage), etc. When micro-organisms that cannot be spread from person to person might play a role, some diseases can be prevented with proper nutrition. Other diseases such
as cancer and heart disease are not considered to be caused by infection. The same is true of mental diseases.
Social significance of disease
The identification of a condition as a disease, rather than as simply a variation of human structure or function, can have significant social or
economic implications. The controversial recognitions as diseases of post-traumatic stress disorder, also known as "Soldier's heart," "shell shock," and "combat fatigue;" repetitive
motion injury or repetitive stress injury (RSI); and Gulf War syndrome has had a number of positive and negative effects on the financial and other responsibilities of governments,
corporations and institutions towards individuals, as well as on the individuals themselves. The social implication of viewing aging as a disease could be profound, though this
classification is not yet widespread.
 A condition may be considered to be a disease in some cultures or eras but not in others. Oppositional-defiant disorder, attention-deficit
hyperactivity disorder, and, increasingly, obesity, are conditions considered to be diseases in the United States and Canada today, but were not so-considered decades ago and
are not so-considered in some other countries. Lepers were a group of afflicted individuals who were historically shunned and the term "leper" still evokes social stigma. Fear of
disease can still be a widespread social phenomena, though not all diseases evoke extreme social stigma.
Sickness confers the social legitimization of certain benefits, such as illness benefits, work avoidance, and being looked after by others.
In return, there is an obligation on the sick person to seek treatment and work to become well once more. As a comparison, consider pregnancy, which is not a state interpreted
as disease or sickness by the individual. On the other hand, it is considered by the medical community as a condition requiring medical care and by society at large as a condition
requiring one's staying at home from work.
Infection
An infection is the detrimental colonization of a host organism by a foreign species. In an infection, the infecting organism seeks to utilize
the host's resources to multiply (usually at the expense of the host). The infecting organism, or pathogen, interferes with the normal functioning of the host and can lead to
chronic wounds, gangrene, loss of an infected limb, and even death. The host's response to infection is inflammation. Colloquially, a pathogen is usually considered a microscopic
organism though the definition is broader, including bacteria, parasites, fungi, viruses, prions, and viroids. A symbiosis between parasite and host, whereby the relationship is
beneficial for the former but detrimental to the latter, is
characterized as parasitism. The branch of medicine that focuses on infections and pathogens is infectious disease.
Colonization
Wound colonization refers to nonreplicating microorganisms within the wound, while in infected wounds replicating organisms exist and
tissue is injured. All multicellular organisms are colonized to some degree by extrinsic organisms, and the vast majority of these exist in either a mutualistic or commensal relationship
with the host. An example of the former would be the anaerobic bacteria species which colonize the mammalian colon, and an example of the latter would be the various species
of staphylococcus which exist on human skin. Neither of these colonizations would be considered infections. The difference between an infection and a colonization is often only a
matter of circumstance. Organisms which are normally non-pathogenic can become pathogenic under the right conditions, and even the most virulent organism requires certain
circumstances to cause a compromising infection. Some colonizing bacteria, such as Corynebacteria sp. and viridans streptococci, prevent the adhesion and colonization of
pathogenic bacteria and thus have a symbiotic relationship with the host, preventing infection and speeding wound healing.
The variables involved in the outcome of a host becoming inoculated by a pathogen and the ultimate outcome include:
| |
|
the route of entry of the pathogen and the access to host regions that it gains |
|
|
the intrinsic virulence of the particular organism |
|
|
the quantity or load of the initial inoculant |
|
|
the immune status of the host being colonized |
As an example, the staphylococcus species present on skin remain harmless on the skin, but, when present in a normally sterile space,
such as in the capsule of a joint or the peritoneum, will multiply without resistance and create a huge burden on the host.
Occult Infection
An occult infection is medical terminology for a "hidden" infection, that is, one which presents no symptoms. Dr. Fran Giampietro
discovered and coined the term "Occult Infection" in the late 1930's.
Inflammation
Inflammation (Latin, inflammatio, to set on fire) is the complex biological response of vascular tissues to harmful stimuli, such as pathogens,
damaged cells, or irritants. It is a protective attempt by the organism to remove the injurious stimuli as well as initiate the healing process for the tissue. Inflammation is not a
synonym for infection. Even in cases where inflammation is caused by infection it is incorrect to use the terms as synonyms: infection is caused by an exogenous pathogen,
while inflammation is the response of the organism to the pathogen.
In the absence of inflammation, wounds and infections would never heal and progressive destruction of the tissue would compromise
the survival of the organism. However, inflammation which runs unchecked can also lead to a host of diseases, such as hay fever, atherosclerosis, and rheumatoid arthritis. It is for
this reason that inflammation is normally tightly regulated by the body.
Inflammation can be classified as either acute or chronic. Acute inflammation is the initial response of the body to harmful stimuli and is
achieved by the increased movement of plasma and leukocytes from the blood into the injured tissues. A cascade of biochemical events propagates and matures the inflammatory
response, involving the local vascular system, the immune system, and various cells within the injured tissue. Prolonged inflammation, known as chronic inflammation, leads to a
progressive shift in the type of cells which are present at the site of inflammation and is characterized by simultaneous destruction and healing of the tissue from the inflammatory
process.
Causes
| |
|
Burns |
|
|
Chemical irritants |
|
|
Frostbite |
|
|
Toxins |
|
|
Infection by pathogens |
|
|
Necrosis |
|
|
Physical injury, blunt or penetrating |
|
|
Immune reactions due to hypersensitivity |
|
|
Ionizing radiation |
|
|
Foreign bodies, including splinters and dirt |
 Acute inflammation is a short-term process which is
characterized by the classic signs of inflammation - swelling, redness, pain, heat, and loss of function - due to the infiltration of the tissues by plasma and leukocytes. It occurs as long as the injurious stimulus is present and ceases once the stimulus has been removed, broken down, or walled off by scarring
|